| PL | Athlete | Team | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Smith, Jesse | Unattached | 42.14m |
| 2 | Laconi, Vince | Indiana Storm TC | 36.40m |
| 3 | Hull, Parker | Unattached | 36.29m |
| 4 | Volmerding, Brandon | Let It Fly Throwing | 36.06m |
| 5 | Bertucci, Jake | Let It Fly Throwing | 35.60m |
| Schall, David | Unattached | ND | |
| Walls, Isaac | Unattached | DNS |